Art Basel Hong Kong 2025 Alert
Worsening Conditions for Free Expression Create Art Market Risks
Summary
Since 2020, the Hong Kong government has systematically suppressed freedom of expression under sweeping and vaguely defined laws targeting sedition and threats to national security. In November 2024, 45 pro-democracy activists including legislators, journalists and academics were sentenced to jail terms of up to 10 years in a landmark trial that has drawn international condemnation. Claiming global reach for its laws the government issued bounties of HK$1 million (US$ 130,000) on nineteen overseas activists. Hong Kong’s jails now hold more than 1,000 political prisoners.
Simultaneously, Hong Kong has continued to invest in trade fairs and international events to project an image of normalcy, and to encourage the perception that global business partners are willing to overlook ongoing human rights abuses. However, as repression increasingly permeates the society, the art business now entails pervasive self-censorship and faces unpredictable risks.
Following the imposition of the National Security Law in 2020, freedom of expression in Hong has been dramatically restricted, and the right to public assembly has been effectively suspended. In March 2024, the introduction of the Safeguarding National Security Ordinance (SNSO) further expanded the scope and severity of penalties for sedition and subversion, with life imprisonment possible in certain cases. A departing judge of Hong Kong’s Court of Final Appeal has described the city as increasingly “totalitarian” and noted that the rule of law has been “profoundly compromised”.
The SNSO prohibits expressions of "hatred or contempt" toward the Chinese government and enables the suppression of historical narratives that deviate from the Party’s version yet lacks clear guidelines regarding what may trigger arrest or prosecution. This uncertainty has fuelled widespread self-censorship among artists, academics, the art market, and private sponsors. International ties are being cut as organizations that once partnered with international defenders of free expression may now be charged with collaborating with ‘external forces’ and can be disbanded by the Secretary for Security.
At the same time, the Hong Kong government continues to allocate substantial funding and support to art events like Art Basel Hong Kong and Art021HK as part of its efforts to position the city as an ‘art and culture hub.’ However, these events operate under national security restrictions that lack clear boundaries and are subject to unpredictable enforcement.
Writing in Forbes in July 2024, Oliva Enos observed, “The business community has tried to act as if it’s business as usual in Hong Kong. But reality is far from that truth. It’s time for the business community and governments around the globe to wake up to the reality that Hong Kong is not the same – in fact, it’s a far riskier place to do business today than ever before.” In Sept 2024, the US State Department also advised that “…similarities between Hong Kong’s and the PRC’s national security laws, combined with Hong Kong’s diminishing autonomy from the central government of the PRC, create new risks for businesses and individuals in Hong Kong that were previously limited to mainland China.” The US has sanctioned Hong Kong Chief Executive John Lee for violating human rights agreements that guarantee freedom of expression and assembly, and along with other countries, has advised against unnecessary travel to the city due to the arbitrary application of its security laws.
The Hong Kong government also claims global jurisdiction over its restrictions on expression. This means that galleries, auction houses, museums, and their employees who operate in Hong Kong are at risk of prosecution if their work or publications, even outside the region, offend the Hong Kong or Chinese governments. To mitigate legal risks this encourages self-censorship which may seem minor or pragmatic to the individuals who undertake it, but which collectively undermines free exchanges in the global art world. It also sets an alarming precedent for like-minded regimes, which will be inspired to impose similar transnational restrictions on arts, culture, and historical memory under the guise of "national security."
This is the stage for Art Basel Hong Kong 2025.
I urge you to consider alternatives for the future.
Full discussion:
Hong Kong: an art hub with political prisoners
1. A Steady Decline in Freedoms (2020-2024)
In June 2020 the Chinese central government imposed the National Security Law (NSL) in Hong Kong, severely restricting freedom of expression, assembly, and other human rights.This move was widely condemned by UN legal experts, the European Union, the US, and numerous NGOs. In its wake, over 60 civil society organizations – including political parties, trade unions and media groups – disbanded, and bounties of HK$1 million (US$ 130,000) were placed on the heads of former elected legislators, trade unionists and democratic activists who had fled abroad (the total number wanted has grown each year, and now stands at 19; none have been successfully extradited to Hong Kong.) In November 2024, 45 pro-democracy activists including legislators, journalists and academics were sentenced to jail terms of up to 10 years in a landmark trial that has drawn international condemnation. Hong Kong’s jails now hold more than 1,000 political prisoners.
By 2023, Hong Kong had fallen to 140th out of 180 in Reporters Without Borders’ World Press Freedom Index, a sharp drop from 73rd before the NSL was enacted. Similarly, in the 2024 Academic Freedom Index, Hong Kong’s universities ranked in the bottom 10 to 20 percent among 179 countries and regions.
Once an open and globally connected city, Hong Kong now regularly denies entry to foreign journalists, academics, and human rights advocates. In just the first nine months of 2024, authorities barred 23,000 visitors deemed to have "suspicious aims."
The international legal community has consistently disagreed with the Hong Kong government’s claims that it is prudently balancing the protection of rights with the need for security. In November 2022 the United Nations Human Rights Committee (an independent group of legal experts) reached these conclusions regarding the National Security Law and Hong Kong’s treaty obligations:
The Committee is concerned about the adverse effect of the overly broad interpretation and arbitrary application of the National Security Law and legislation on sedition, and its impact on the exercise of freedom of expression. This includes: (a) the closure of media outlets, in some cases voluntarily for fear of reprisals, raids on their offices and freezing of their assets; (b) the blocking of websites and media accounts and the removal of online content; (c) the arrest and arbitrary detention of journalists, politicians, academics, students and human rights defenders who have expressed dissenting opinions; (d) intimidation, attacks or threat of attacks against journalists; (e) censorship; (f) interference with the editorial independence of public media outlets such as Radio Television Hong Kong; and (g) difficulties in obtaining or renewing visas for foreign journalists, among others.
The United Nations Human Rights Committee advised that the NSL be suspended. This advice was rejected by the Hong Kong government. In June 2023 the European Parliament called on the Hong Kong authorities to “restore the freedom of speech and the media freedom, in particular by repealing the National Security Law which is in breach of the international law”.
In March 2024, restrictions were further tightened with the passage of Hong Kong’s Safeguarding National Security Ordinance (SNSO). For the first time, this legislation incorporates into Hong Kong law the broad national security concepts advanced by Communist Party leader Xi Jinping, which are now a part of Chinese law.
Xi's comprehensive interpretation of national security covers all aspects of life and the economy, including ‘cultural security,’ providing grounds for criminalizing opinions on current affairs or history that diverge from the Party’s—or the Hong Kong government’s—narrative. Although Hong Kong officials claim they are open to criticism, it is only permitted when it involves factual corrections. In August 2024, two editors of Stand News were convicted of conspiring to publish seditious materials after reporting public criticism. Stand News was shut down, and its assets were frozen by police.
The security laws have greatly expanded police powers and toughened conditions for arrests and prosecutions. Police can now search any premises or devices, demand information, freeze assets, confiscate passports, intercept communications, and conduct covert surveillance without prior judicial approval if they suspect a national security threat. The presumption of bail has been removed, often resulting in prolonged pretrial detention. Cases are adjudicated by hand-picked judges, and in ‘serious cases,’ defendants may be transferred to mainland courts for trial.
Lest people in the arts imagine this does not affect them, Secretary for Security Chris Tang has emphasized the importance of remaining alert to the “attempts of external forces and their agents in Hong Kong” to bring hatred against the central authorities and the special administrative region government through media, culture and arts, and other means of “soft resistance”. According to Tang, art is a “a common modus operandi of those seeking to endanger national security to engage in such acts and activities under the pretexts of ‘peaceful advocacy,’ ‘artistic creations’ and so forth.”
Authorities have broad, unchecked discretion in determining whether art or other forms of expression constitute a crime or criminal intent. For convictions under the crime of ‘incitement to sedition,’ no proof of motive is needed—only a judge’s assessment that something ‘could’ influence another person to commit sedition.
In April 2024 the European Parliament stated that it “[s]trongly condemns the SNSO’s adoption, which erases the last vestiges of fundamental freedoms in HK; is appalled at the shutting down of pro-democracy political forces, civil society and news outlets and the arrest of over 200 people since the NSL’s adoption; urges the PRC and HK to repeal the NSL and SNSO.” The European Parliament also called for sanctions against Chief Executive John Lee and other government officials. The Hong Kong government accused the parliamentarians of “malicious intentions.”
2. Censorship and Intimidation
Under Xi Jinping’s leadership, China has witnessed a steady erosion of artistic freedom, with a return to Mao Zedong’s view of culture as a tool to be controlled by the Party. It is asserted that art should serve a "nationalistic purpose", promoting "correct perspectives on history, nationality, statehood, and culture." Artists, academics and critics in the PRC have seen independent spaces disappear and are expected to express fealty to Xi Jinping Thought and develop art and culture ‘with Chinese characteristics.’ (The scope and mechanisms are described by Kejia Wu, in A Modern History of China's Art Market, Routledge, 2023.)
This strict regulation of culture has made its way to Hong Kong faster than many anticipated. Defending the 2023 removal of hundreds of books from public libraries, Chief Executive John Lee claimed that the government has a duty to eliminate works with "bad ideologies." In 2024, liberal studies in schools were replaced by lessons on Xi Jinping Thought. The remaining independent bookstores are regularly harassed by government agencies seeking to find minor infractions, while attendees to book fairs have been stopped and searched by police. In this climate of fear, public art expressions have become sanitised and cautious. Satire and mockery have no place. There are no longer any funny pictures of Xi Jinping as Winnie-the-Pooh.
Concerns about national security now permeate every aspect of life in Hong Kong. A siege mentality and culture of surveillance have taken hold, with government employees—including those working in museums and cultural services—being instructed to prioritize national security in their work.
National security obligations have also been written into government contracts and sponsorship agreements, holding recipients of public funds accountable for the actions of their employees, agents, and event participants. Breaches of these clauses can result in financial penalties as well as legal consequences. These conditions were included in the Mega Arts and Cultural Events Fund sponsorship agreements with Art Basel Hong Kong in 2023 and 2024, as well as the 2024 Art021HK art fair and Art Central 2025.
National security concerns are causing international auction houses in Hong Kong to exclude artworks that were previously sold without issue. This includes Chinese paintings from the 1990s that feature Pop-style imagery of Mao Zedong or works that are ‘disrespectful’ of Chinese history, the Party, or the military. The auction houses attribute these exclusions to "unfavourable market conditions" in their explanations to disappointed sellers.
Prudent concern ‘to avoid trouble’ has led private landlords to remove artworks. One of the most dramatic censorships of public art came when the management of Hong Kong University removed Jens Galschiøt’s Tiananmen Massacre-themed artwork, the Pillar of Shame, which had stood on the Hong Kong University campus for over twenty years and had been a focus for memorial events. Citing “safety” concerns, the university sealed the site and removed the sculpture in the dead of night in December 2021. The work was subsequently seized and continues to be held by the Hong Kong police as evidence in an unspecified case of subversion of state power. Government-aligned newspapers reported in August 2023 that Galschiøt himself could be subject to a secret arrest warrant, with transfer of trial to mainland China owing to the severity of the threat to national security. The Secretary of Security will neither confirm nor deny this.
Removal of a prominent temporary artwork also occurred in March 2023 during the annual Art Week coinciding with Art Basel Hong Kong. The video work, No Rioters, by Patrick Amadon was shown on a 70 x 20 metre LED screen owned by the Sogo department store in Causeway Bay. The work contained the names and other information about suspects held for political crimes. These appeared in what seemed to be glitches in the video stream and could only be clearly read in still photos. Owing to this the content was not recognised for several days. After it was discovered, Sogo removed the work but would not say whether this was in response to calls from the government.
Art in media outlets is increasingly controlled. In May 2023, political cartoonist Wong Kei-kwan, known for his satirical depictions of local politics, was dropped by Ming Pao newspaper after government officials criticized his work. Despite previously winning government-sponsored book prizes, Wong’s works were later removed from public libraries.
Even brief public street performances are tightly monitored. On 3 June 2024, in the bustling shopping district of Causeway Bay, performance artist Sanmu Chan (Chen Shi Sen) silently traced the Chinese characters for “8964” (八九六四in the air with his finger, then mimed pouring wine onto the ground to mourn those killed at Tiananmen on 4 June 1989. Hong Kong police officers watched the entire performance before moving in to detain him. This was one of several instances of zero tolerance of any remembrance of what the authorities called an “upcoming sensitive date”.
Sponsorship and access to platforms are becoming more limited. According to one curator, there is now frequent “systematic vetting of artists for even minor risks, and often choosing or pressuring organisations not to do an event.” Printers refuse projects they believe could offend the government or the Communist Party.
Fear and rumours of impending arrest have led some artists to flee Hong Kong. This includes the performance artist Kacey Wong and the political cartoonist vawongsir. The painting duo Lumli Lumlong (a pseudonym), left the city in 2021 after being accused by the media of promoting Hong Kong independence. Their book Liberarts was subsequently banned. Like many other exiled artists, they have had to sever ties in Hong Kong due to concerns that their family and friends could face police harassment.
Among the artists who remain in Hong Kong, caution now replaces risk-taking, often at the urging of concerned colleagues. Curators and critics engage in collective self-censorship, steering each other away from political or social critique. As one artist lamented, “There are no red lines—everything is red.”
3. Transnational Repression and Global Risks
The Hong Kong government asserts the right to prosecute not only those who commit offenses within its borders, but also anyone, anywhere in the world—regardless of nationality—whom it deems to have violated its national security laws. In July 2023, Secretary for Security Tang stated that police would seek to trace suspects’ “contacts, allies and [people] funding them behind the scenes,” adding that “anyone who assists, incites or funds those people to endanger national security in Hong Kong and [mainland China] may breach the law.” For example, a gallerist exhibiting artwork abroad that the Hong Kong government views as violating its laws could face prosecution if they later enter Hong Kong. Although such cases have yet to occur, the safety of you and your employees could be at risk in similar scenarios.
The SNSO also criminalizes ‘collusion with external forces,’ a term so vaguely defined that it could include something as simple as an email exchange with a critic or an interview with a journalist. Justice Minister Paul Lam has warned that re-posting overseas criticisms of the Hong Kong government may be illegal. While the list of foreign enemies remains flexible, officials have identified human rights defenders and even UN agencies. This uncertainty pushes those in the arts to limit or self-censor their international connections.
4. Seek Alternative Platforms for the Future
I understand that this letter comes too late for you to withdraw from the upcoming Art Basel Hong Kong, but I strongly encourage you to reconsider your future participation. The Hong Kong authorities and the Party are increasingly enforcing a restricted, censored vision of culture that you cannot afford to align with. The potential business risks and damage to your reputation from participating in the fair far outweigh the benefits. I urge you to explore alternative platforms and events in the region.
I also urge this year to review of your human rights position. Resources to assist this include: the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights; the OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises on Responsible Business Conduct; and the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights guide on The Corporate Responsibility to Respect Human Rights. Additional resources are available from multi-
stakeholder efforts such as the Global Network Initiative.
Finally, a last word about what is at stake, from the Polish novelist Witold Gombrowicz who spent most of his life in exile in Argentina: “It is probably a complete misunderstanding to conceive of serious art in categories of production, market, readers, supply and demand—what does this have to do with anything?” Art is risky, elusive, “where one can preserve flight, pride, joke, confession, rapture, play, struggle.” Excerpt from Diary (1961)
Eric Wear is a former president of the Hong Kong section of the International Association of Art Critics (AICA) and currently a member of the Freedom of Expression and Censorship Committee at the international level of AICA. His comments on restrictions in Hong Kong have been carried by The Guardian, Reuters, RFA and NBC News and Jornal de Brasília. He has also written about this in The Diplomat (March 2024 and June 2024) and the journal of the International Association of Art Critics (AICA). In March 2024, he spoke to members of the European Parliament about the potential for Hong Kong’s transnational repression of the arts. He no longer lives in Hong Kong, and in view of the potential legal consequences of this letter and other statements under Hong Kong's national security laws, he will refrain from returning there.